Featuring news articles and press releases, blog posts, and legal publications, firm attorneys and developments in the law.

Serious Injury Threshold in New York State

Serious Injury Threshold in New York State

New York state is one of the busiest areas in the country. People are constantly coming and going, leading to significant traffic almost around the clock.

With over 450,000 accidents a year, most people in New York have been involved in an accident or know someone who has. While these situations can be scary and overwhelming, the state has taken steps to make it possible for accident victims to recover the compensation needed quickly, thanks to no-fault laws.

However, what happens if the compensation provided by someone’s insurance isn’t enough? Can they file a lawsuit? What requirements must be met?

At The Law Offices of Joseph J. Perrini, III, we are here to help. Knowing and understanding the “serious injury threshold” is necessary in these situations. This requirement must be met to have the right to file a lawsuit.

Our legal team is ready to help you with this legal process. Learn more about the serious injury threshold in New York State and how we can help here.

Legal Definition in New York State

In New York, the “Serious Injury Threshold” is a legal criterion outlined in New York Insurance Law Section 5102(d). A “serious injury” is a personal injury resulting in death, dismemberment, significant disfigurement, fracture, or loss of a fetus. Additional criteria include any injury leading to permanent loss or impairment of a body organ, member, function, or system.

Role in Personal Injury Lawsuits

The Serious Injury Threshold is essential in New York personal injury lawsuits. If your injuries don’t align with the legal “serious injury” criteria, you cannot file a lawsuit for non-economic damages like pain and suffering. You may, however, still pursue economic damages such as medical expenses and lost income.

Distinction Between “Minor” and “Serious” Injuries

Understanding the difference between “minor” and “serious” injuries is critical. Minor injuries like sprains, scrapes, or bruises usually do not meet the Serious Injury Threshold in New York. On the other hand, “serious injuries” encompass conditions like fractured bones, severe burns, or any injury leading to permanent impairment.

Impact on Eligibility to File a Lawsuit

The Serious Injury Threshold is a gatekeeper in New York personal injury cases. If your injury doesn’t meet this legal standard, you’re restricted from filing a lawsuit for non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering. Understanding the threshold is a critical first step in any personal injury claim.

Significance in Potential Compensation

Meeting the Serious Injury Threshold opens the door to a broader compensation range. In addition to economic damages like medical bills and lost wages, you can seek compensation for emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, and other non-economic damages. This can significantly increase the overall value of your settlement or court award.

Role in Determining the Litigation Process

The Serious Injury Threshold also shapes the legal strategy and litigation process. Meeting this criterion allows us to advocate for comprehensive compensation, affecting how we approach negotiations, settlements, and, if necessary, court proceedings.

Categories of Serious Injuries

Not all injuries meet the “serious injury threshold.” The ones that do include the following:


Fractures are one of the more straightforward categories that meet the Serious Injury Threshold in New York. These are not just simple broken bones but often involve compound fractures or injuries requiring surgical intervention. For example, you meet the threshold if you have a compound fracture from a car accident.


Dismemberment refers to severing a limb or other body part and is a condition that qualifies under the Serious Injury Threshold. Victims of workplace accidents involving heavy machinery often fall into this category.


If a personal injury case results in death, the Serious Injury Threshold is unquestionably met. This allows the deceased’s estate and family to file for economic and non-economic damages, including loss of consortium and emotional distress.

Loss of a Fetus

The loss of a fetus due to someone else’s negligence also meets the Serious Injury Threshold, allowing the mother to pursue a comprehensive personal injury claim, including non-economic damages.

Others, as Specified Under New York Law

New York law also includes other types of injuries like significant disfigurement, permanent loss of a bodily organ, function, or system, and temporary total disability for 90 out of 180 days following the accident. These can qualify as a “serious injury,” opening the path to a broader compensation range.

Criteria for Meeting the Serious Injury Threshold

To file a lawsuit, knowing and meeting the threshold requirements is necessary. These requirements include:

Medical Evaluations and Reports

Obtaining thorough medical evaluations and reports is critical to establishing your case. Doctors’ assessments, medical tests, and treatment records serve as objective evidence to prove the seriousness of your injuries.

Testimonies and Evidence

Eyewitness testimonies, accident reports, and photographic evidence can further substantiate your claim. These elements can provide additional context and support, bolstering the medical evidence.

Role of Legal Representation

Experienced legal representation is crucial in navigating the complexities of the Serious Injury Threshold. We help gather evidence, consult medical experts, and build a compelling case that meets the legal criteria.

Common Hurdles and Challenges

Some common challenges include insufficient medical evidence, statutes of limitations, or disputes from the opposing party questioning the severity of the injury. These hurdles can be mitigated with a solid legal strategy and thorough preparation.

How Joseph J. Perrini, III Can Assist You

When navigating the complexities of New York’s personal injury laws, including the Serious Injury Threshold, the expertise of The Law Offices of Joseph J. Perrini, III stands out. We have a proven track record of successfully representing clients in cases that hinge on meeting this threshold. Our success stories range from car accident cases to work-related injuries that meet the strict “serious injury” criteria, enabling our clients to secure the comprehensive compensation they deserve.

Choosing us for your legal representation means you’re not just hiring a lawyer but partnering with a team committed to your well-being and justice. We handle the heavy lifting—from gathering evidence to consulting medical experts—so you can focus on your recovery.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How Soon Should You Consult a Lawyer?

If you’ve been in an accident and suspect you’ve suffered a serious injury, consult with a lawyer immediately. Early legal guidance can be pivotal in building a strong case.

What If You Are Unsure If Your Injuries Meet the Threshold?

If you’re uncertain whether your injuries meet the Serious Injury Threshold, it’s still crucial to consult with us. We can evaluate your case, review medical records, and offer expert advice on proceeding.

Understanding the Serious Injury Threshold and how it impacts your case is vital, and we are here to guide you every step of the way.

Navigating the Complexities of the Serious Injury Threshold in Personal Injury Cases

Understanding the Serious Injury Threshold in New York is more than just a legal requirement; it’s a crucial element that can impact the outcome of your personal injury case. This threshold plays a significant role in shaping your legal journey, from eligibility to file a lawsuit to the types of compensation you can seek.

We’re committed to guiding you through this intricate landscape at The Law Offices of Joseph J. Perrini, III. Our expertise in New York’s personal injury laws and our proven track record in cases involving the Serious Injury Threshold make us the ideal choice for your legal representation.

If you’re facing a personal injury, don’t navigate these complicated matters alone. Contact us for advice and dedicated personal injury attorney will discuss your needs. We’re here to help you focus on what truly matters—your recovery.

Share it

Related Blogs